Well, this ended up being found in our favor thanks to his Ebay listing! We'll be receiving his original payment back, and he will now owe Paypal $750 plus before he can use his account anymore. Mail fraud charges will be filed against them next now that we have documented proof of our case being decided in our favor.
Thanks to Justin for originally posting the auction link, and to everyone else for their support with this.
Thanks to Justin for originally posting the auction link, and to everyone else for their support with this.